Is it just me or have we all entered some kind of Twilight Zone in which torture and terror are okay as long as the defenders of freedom and democracy are using them?

This past Saturday, March 9th, President Bush exercised his veto on a piece of legislation that would have banned interrogation techniques used by the CIA, such as waterboarding. In his weekly radio address he stated,

“The bill Congress sent me would take away one of the most valuable tools in the war on terror […] so today I vetoed it”

What is Waterboarding?

This incredibly controversial interrogation technique/ form of torture, depending on who is talking, originated in the 16th century during the Italian inquisition.

A bound and gagged prisoner is immobilized on his back, head tilted downward. Water is then poured over him, causing an immediate gag reflex and simulating drowning. Often, cellophane is also placed over the prisoner’s face—further preventing him from taking any air. (remember how your parents told you not to place saran wrap over your face when you were little….)

While even reading descriptions of this procedure makes me feel horribly ill, others claim that waterboarding is a valid interrogation technique to use on terrorists.

Fox news correspondent Steve Harrigan allowed himself to be waterboarded on the air to show his viewers, “what exactly it is,” whether it is “torture,” and if “the U.S. [should] use it.”

His conclusions:

“ …the thing that really impressed me was just how quickly you can recover. I mean, they took me to the brink, where I was ready to submit, tell them anything within minutes, and then, just minutes later, I was standing by the side of that pool feeling fine. So, as far as torture goes, at least in this controlled experiment, to me, this seemed like a pretty efficient mechanism to get someone to talk and then still have them alive and healthy within minutes.”

Ok, so besides his insensitively flippant attitude about the issue, there are some major problems with this statement.
First of all let’s define “healthy”.

Nathaniel Raymond of the Physicians for Human Rights’ Campaign Against Torture reveals that the violent choking caused by waterboarding results in throat spasms damaging the lungs, larynx and esophagus. Also, the deprivation of oxygen may lead to myocardial infarction.

Waterboarding also is deeply psychologically traumatic. Raymond states.

“We had one Turkish individual who was waterboarded and who is now unable to go out in the rain and is afraid of showering.”

Second of all, torture is PROHIBITED under international law. Human Rights Watch wrote an open letter to Attorney General Alberto Gonzales in April 2006, in which they make a detailed argument against the usage of abusive interrogation techniques.

You all know the response to such claims:
“Why do Human Rights matter? We are in a war against terrorists who want to kill us!!” Bush obviously had this mindset when he argued that the CIA shouldn’t be deprived of such an important tool.

There are two answers I have to this:
1. Who is a terrorist and where do you draw the line? Take a moment to think about this. In many countries, the army is just as complicit in terrorizing as the guerilla fighters. In this country couldn’t we call some gangs terrorists? I grew up in the Los Angeles area during the Rodney King riots. The city was on fire. Isn’t that “terrorism?” What about those who fight for freedom—“freedom fighters”—those who sabotage a government in an effort to destabilize a repressive regime.

Without a definition of the enemy, we run the risk of fighting an endless and morally dangerous war.

2. This brings me to my second answer, denying a certain group of people their human rights is a treacherous path to embark upon. The process of dehumanization truly is a domino-like process as this past century tells us.

Regardless of whether you agree with the current trajectory of the War on Terror or think that Bush is the anti-Christ, it is essential to realize that maintaining practices such as waterboarding even against terrorists has universal implications and for that reason must be stopped.

Torture is NEVER the answer.